Alexander Elder
Psychiatrist-turned-trader behind the Triple Screen system and the 2% and 6% risk rules
- Born
- Leningrad (now St Petersburg), USSR; raised in Estonia
- Early life
- Entered medical school at 16; at 23, as a ship’s doctor, left a Soviet vessel in Africa and won US political asylum
- Career
- Psychiatrist in New York and Columbia University faculty member; later a full-time trader and educator
- Best-known book
- Trading for a Living (1993)
- Founded
- SpikeTrade, a worldwide traders’ group; week-long Traders’ Camps
Biography
Alexander Elder was born in Leningrad and grew up in Estonia, entering medical school at 16. At 23, while serving as a ship’s doctor on a Soviet vessel, he walked off the ship in an African port and was granted political asylum in the United States.
In New York he practised as a psychiatrist and taught at Columbia University. He carried his clinical eye into the markets: most traders, in his view, lose not for want of information but for want of self-control. That idea runs through everything he has written since.
Trading for a Living, published in 1993, organised trading around three pillars — psychology, method and money management — and became a standard primer on technical trading, translated into more than a dozen languages. Come Into My Trading Room (2002) and Entries & Exits (2007) followed, each winning book-of-the-year honours, and an overhauled edition, The New Trading for a Living, appeared in 2014.
Today he trades full-time and teaches. He founded SpikeTrade, a worldwide group of traders, runs week-long Traders’ Camps and is a regular speaker at investment conferences in the US and abroad.
Investment philosophy
The enemy is in the mirror
His recurring theme is psychology: fear keeps traders from taking losses, greed keeps them from taking profits, and ego makes them argue with the market and add to losing positions. A trading system’s first job is to protect traders from their own worst instincts.
Mind, Method, Money
He sums up successful trading as three Ms. Good indicators without money management, or rules without self-discipline, will not get a trader far.
Survival comes first
What ruins traders, he argues, is less a single big loss than the urge to win it back after a losing streak. Hard limits on losses keep a trader in the game.
Keep books like a business
He urges traders to write a plan and keep a journal — recording the reason for each trade, the prices, the result and their state of mind — and to review it to find their habitual mistakes.
Method
Finding trades: the Triple Screen
His best-known method, the Triple Screen, was first published in Futures magazine in 1986. It filters signals through three timeframes. The first screen uses a trend indicator on a longer chart, such as the weekly, to set the direction — trades are only allowed with that tide.
Timing entries
The second screen uses an oscillator — an indicator of whether prices have run too far, too fast — on a shorter chart such as the daily to wait for a counter-move: in an uptrend, look to buy when the daily is briefly oversold. The third screen pins down the exact entry with a specific order price, so the trader does not jump in before the pullback is over.
Sizing: the 2% rule
No single trade may risk more than 2% of account equity. Set the stop first, then work out the position size from the risk per share or contract — not the other way round.
Risk control: the 6% rule
Once a month’s realised losses plus the open risk on current positions reach 6% of the account’s value at the start of the month, no new trades until the next month. It forces a cooling-off period exactly when a trader is most tempted to chase losses.
Tools
He devised Elder-ray, which gauges bull and bear power by the distance of daily highs and lows from an exponential moving average, and the Force Index, which multiplies price change by volume to measure the strength behind a move. Both are usually read alongside moving averages.
When wrong
Take the stop and log the trade for review. If losses hit the 6% line, stop trading until next month rather than sizing up to win it back.
Landmark trades
- 1986
The Triple Screen goes public
He distilled his multi-timeframe filtering into the Triple Screen system and published it in Futures magazine. The idea — set direction on the longer chart, time entries on the shorter one — was later built into Trading for a Living and remains one of the most cited templates for multi-timeframe analysis.
- 1993
Trading for a Living
The book put trading psychology on an equal footing with technical indicators, dissecting traders’ emotional traps alongside tools such as the Triple Screen, Elder-ray and the Force Index. It went through many printings before a fully revised edition in 2014.
- 2002
Come Into My Trading Room and the money rules
Here he codified risk control into two hard limits — the 2% and 6% rules — and stressed record-keeping and review. Many trading textbooks now treat those two rules as a starting point for risk management.
Limits & controversies
- His influence rests on his books and teaching; there is no audited public record of his own trading, so the method’s real-world results are hard to judge independently.
- The Triple Screen depends on indicator and parameter choices. In trendless markets the long-term direction flips often and the screens can give conflicting signals.
- The 2% and 6% limits are conservative rules of thumb: they help prevent blow-ups but do not guarantee profits, and for very small accounts a 2% risk budget can make positions impractically small.
How WhyNext uses this framework
When WhyNext cites Alexander Elder, it checks whether weekly and daily charts point the same way: only when the longer trend is up is a short daily pullback treated as a with-the-trend setup worth watching. His risk rules are also used as a reminder about position size and emotions after a losing streak.
Further reading
- Trading for a Living: Psychology, Trading Tactics, Money Management 1993
- Come Into My Trading Room 2002
- Entries & Exits 2007
- The New Trading for a Living 2014
Sources
- https://play.google.com/store/info/name/Alexander_Elder?id=05sk4r
- https://stockcharts.com/articles/bios/alexander-elder.html
- https://www.incrediblecharts.com/trading/6_percent_rule.php
- https://dailyforex.com/forex-articles/2020/09/elder-triple-screen-system/151378
- https://www.tenlong.com.tw/products/9781118443927
Compiled from public sources, with facts checked against them. The method section summarises public statements; it is not the investor's own words and not investment advice.