Richard Dennis
The Chicago pit trader who set out to prove trend-following could be taught — the Turtle experiment
- Born
- January 1949, Chicago
- Education
- BA in philosophy, DePaul University
- Role
- Commodities speculator; president of Dennis Trading Group
- Starting stake
- Borrowed $1,600 from family; after buying an exchange seat about $400 was left to trade
- Known for
- Recruited and trained 23 ‘Turtle’ traders in 1983–84
Biography
Richard Dennis was born in Chicago in 1949. At 17 he was working as an order runner on the floor of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange. He studied philosophy at DePaul University and was offered a graduate scholarship in philosophy at Tulane, but turned it down and went back to the pits.
He borrowed $1,600 from his family, spent about $1,200 on a seat at the MidAmerica Commodity Exchange — an entry-level floor for ‘mini’ contracts — and started trading with the roughly $400 left over. Still below the exchange’s minimum age of 21, he ran his own orders and hired his father to stand in the pit. The inflationary 1970s were kind to a trend trader: his capital passed $100,000 in 1973, and a $500,000 profit in soybeans in 1974 made him a millionaire before his 26th birthday. By the late 1970s he had bought a full membership at the Chicago Board of Trade.
In 1983 he fell into an argument with his friend and fellow trader William Eckhardt over whether great traders are born or made. Richard Dennis bet they could be made. The pair placed ads in The Wall Street Journal, Barron’s and The New York Times asking for no experience at all, picked 23 people from more than a thousand applicants, trained them for about two weeks in two classes (December 1983 and December 1984), and handed them between $250,000 and $2m of Richard Dennis’s own money. The ‘Turtles’ reportedly made an aggregate profit of about $175m over roughly five years, and several went on to run their own firms.
The late 1980s were brutal. He reportedly lost about $10m around the 1987 crash and some $50m across 1987–88, and in spring 1988 he stopped managing outside money after heavy client losses. In 1990 his firm paid more than $2.5m to settle investor complaints that he had not followed his own trading rules, without admitting or denying wrongdoing. He managed funds again in the mid-to-late 1990s before shutting down after losses in the summer of 2000. Outside markets he has been a prominent campaigner against drug prohibition, chairing the advisory board of the Drug Policy Alliance and serving on the boards of the Cato Institute and the Reason Foundation.
Investment philosophy
Trading can be taught
The Turtle experiment rested on one claim: give ordinary people clear rules and make them follow those rules, and they can learn to trade. Richard Dennis turned what looked like talent into a written system.
Follow the trend, don’t call the turn
He did not try to forecast prices. He waited for the market to break into a trend and went with it — an approach that thrived in the inflationary 1970s and in episodes such as the 1972 ‘Great Grain Robbery’, when Soviet buying sent US grain prices soaring.
A few big wins pay for many small losses
Trend-following wins less often than it loses. Many trades end in small losses; the money is made in a handful of long runs. Losses therefore have to be kept small and winners left alone.
Rules beat gut feel
He made his trainees trade mechanically because fear and greed tend to override sound decisions at exactly the wrong moment. Ironically, the 1990 investor settlement centred on whether he himself had strayed from his rules.
Method
Finding opportunities
Stick to liquid futures markets — bonds, currencies, energy, metals, grains — and wait for prices to break out of their recent range. According to TurtleTrader, the Turtles used two entry systems: a faster one keyed to 20-day highs and lows and a slower one keyed to 55-day breakouts.
When to get in
Buy a new range high, sell short a new range low. No waiting for a pullback, no need for a news story to explain the move. The conditions are written down in advance and acted on when they trigger.
Sizing
Position size was driven by volatility. The Turtles used a measure called ‘N’ — roughly the average true range, or how far a market typically moves in a day — to set the number of contracts so that each market carried similar risk. They added to winners in steps (pyramiding) and cut size during losing stretches.
Risk control
Every trade had an exit point fixed before entry, so any single loss was a small slice of the account. Total exposure was capped as well, so that several correlated positions could not blow up together.
When wrong
Hit the exit, get out — no averaging down, no rewriting the rules. Strings of small losses are the price of admission; the real danger is abandoning the system after a few of them and missing the big trend that follows.
Landmark trades
- 1974
A soybean fortune
Starting from roughly $400, his stake passed $3,000 in 1970 and $100,000 in 1973. In 1974 he made about $500,000 trading soybeans and became a millionaire before turning 26. It was a decade of commodity inflation, and unlike most floor traders, who scalped in and out within the day, he held positions for longer and often added to winners.
- 1983–1988
The Turtle experiment
To settle his bet with William Eckhardt he advertised for novices, picked 23 of them, trained them for about two weeks and gave them real money. The Turtles reportedly earned about $175m in aggregate over roughly five years, and graduates such as Jerry Parker went on to run well-known trend-following funds. The rules were later laid out in books including Curtis Faith’s Way of the Turtle.
- 1987–1988
Heavy losses around the crash
According to The New York Times and other reports, he lost about $10m around the October 1987 crash and roughly $50m over 1987–88. He stopped managing client money in spring 1988, and in 1990 his firm settled investor complaints for more than $2.5m. Even a well-built trend system can suffer deep, prolonged drawdowns.
Limits & controversies
- In choppy, range-bound markets trend-following gets whipsawed by false breakouts, and runs of small losses can last a long time — a severe psychological test.
- Once the rules became public and widely copied, the edge faded: back-tests cited on Wikipedia show the Turtle system’s performance falling sharply after 1986 and going roughly flat from 1996 to 2009.
- Richard Dennis himself closed his outside business after losses in 1987–88 and again in 2000, and paid to settle complaints that he had not followed his own rules — a reminder that knowing a system and sticking to it are different things.
How WhyNext uses this framework
When WhyNext cites Richard Dennis, it is asking whether markets such as crude oil, gold, copper or the major currencies have broken out of their 20- or 55-day ranges, and whether conditions look like a trending market or a choppy one. It is a lens for judging whether a trend is in place, not a trading signal.
Further reading
- Market Wizards (Jack D. Schwager; includes an interview with Richard Dennis) 1989
- Way of the Turtle (Curtis Faith) 2007
- The Complete TurtleTrader (Michael W. Covel) 2009
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Dennis
- https://www.turtletrader.com/richard-dennis-turtle-want-ad/
- http://www.turtletrader.com/rules/
Compiled from public sources, with facts checked against them. The method section summarises public statements; it is not the investor's own words and not investment advice.