Back-dated report: this page was recalculated with the current model and the data published up to 2020-03-20; it was not published live at the time. Charts, analogs and band odds use only information available up to that day. But the model itself was designed on the full 2006–2026 sample, and some macro data are revised figures, so hindsight bias remains; read it with that discount in mind.
High top risk: the index is 32% off its high and internals are weakening across the board; credit and jobs are starting to confirm
SPY 228.80, 32.4% below its 52-week high · Type 2 · cycle turn (historically mostly U- or L-shaped)
Key points this week
■
Top-risk score 86.7, high risk, +2.3 on last week (10-year percentile: 100%). In back-tests, of the 167 weeks with SPY more than 3% off its 52-week high and a score in the same band, 38% were followed by a drawdown of 10% or more within 3 months (the top probability); the average for all weeks in that position is only 23%, so this band runs at 1.6× the average.
■
Cracks come from: Credit spread widening off 1-year low +205bp (score 100); % of stocks above 200-day line (top 1,000 by liquidity) 6.8% (score 100); New highs − new lows, 10-day average -32.1% (score 100).
■
Not yet confirming: Days the A/D line has lagged SPY's new high 0 days (score 38). If these turn higher, the score moves into a higher band.
■
Fuel 20 (Buffett indicator (market cap / GDP) 160% (score 100); Equity risk premium (1/CAPE − real rate) +3.41% (score 53); Shiller CAPE 24.8x (score 41)). Fuel sets how far a market falls once it breaks; in back-tests it had no timing power, so it is left out of the headline score.
■
Biggest moves this week: Equity risk premium (1/CAPE − real rate) +33 pts; BTC 3-month gain +21 pts; AAII bull–bear spread, 4-week average -20 pts.
■
Type: Type 2 · cycle turn (historically mostly U- or L-shaped).
Top-risk score
86.7
High risk▲ +2.3 on the week
Top probability (≥10% fall within 3 months)
38%
Same-position average 23% · this band is 1.6× that
Historical frequency of a ≥10% SPY drawdown within 3 months · sample: 167 weeks in the same band with SPY more than 3% off its 52-week high
Exhibit 1: Odds of a fall over the next 1 and 3 months: this week's band vs the historical average
Scenario
This week (high risk)
Same-position avg.
This week vs avg.
All-week avg. (ref.)
Fall ≥5% within 1 month
35%
26%
1.4× (+9 pts)
18%
Fall ≥5% within 3 months
54%
40%
1.4× (+14 pts)
34%
Fall ≥10% within 3 months
38%
23%
1.6× (+14 pts)
15%
Same-position average = all past weeks in which SPY was more than 3% off its 52-week high; this week = the 167 of those weeks whose score was in the same band (high risk). Multiples and percentage points compare this week with the same-position average (computed on unrounded odds). Fall = SPY's maximum drawdown from that week's close within the window. Sample 2006-09-08 → 2019-12-13, only weeks whose outcome was known by this week.
1. Score history
Exhibit 2: Top-risk score and SPY (past 3 years, weekly)
Note: headline score = crack score; fuel is background only. Shading shows the bands; red vertical lines are the historical tops used for calibration. Sources: Polygon, CBOE, FRED, CFTC, AAII, CNN, FINRA, multpl; WhyNext calculations.
Exhibit 6: Closest historical analogs (nearest on the six class scores, one per quarter)
Date
Distance
Score then
Next 13 wks return
Next 13 wks max drawdown
2016-01-29
18
75.4
+6.5%
-3.7%
2015-09-04
26
66.6
+8.8%
0.1%
2018-12-21
30
76.2
+16.0%
2.9%
Note: similar is not the same; small sample, for reference only. Sources: Polygon, CBOE, FRED, CFTC, AAII, CNN, FINRA, multpl; WhyNext calculations.
3. What would prove us wrong
■ Cracks are elevated. If the equal-weight/cap-weight drawdown narrows to within 3%, leading sectors return to 52-week highs and credit spreads fall back near their 1-year low, the cracks were false and the score should come down.
■ Fuel is not high: even if cracks appear, the expected decline is moderate (more like the 10–19% pullbacks of July 2023 or February 2025).
■ The Type 2 call rests on the yield curve and the Taylor-rule gap. If credit spreads and jobless claims stop rising, the cycle-turn call weakens to a mid-cycle (V-shaped) pullback.
4. Track record and method
Exhibit 7: All history up to this week: score (4-week average) and SPY drawdown; red lines = Type 2 tops, blue lines = Type 1 tops
Exhibit 8: Historical outcomes by band (weeks with SPY within 3% of its 52-week high)
Band
Score
Weeks
Fall ≥5% in 1 month
Fall ≥5% in 3 months
Fall ≥10% in 3 months
Low risk
< 40
279
9%
23%
5%
Moderate risk
40–50
69
16%
38%
4%
Elevated risk
50–60
27
18%
37%
26%
High risk
≥ 60
18
33%
89%
56%
Average
393
12%
30%
9%
Sample 2006-09-08 → 2019-12-13 (only weeks whose outcome was known by this week); the ≥60 band rests on only a handful of independent episodes, so treat it as a rough scale, not a precise probability.
Predictive power (outcomes known by this week only): with SPY near its high, the score's AUC for a ≥10% drawdown over the next 13 weeks is 0.68 (0.5 = no predictive power); the base rate is 9%, against 24% for the top-scoring 20% of weeks. Method: 27 indicators in 6 classes are first aligned for publication lag, then converted to rolling 10-year percentiles (using only data available before that date). The headline score uses only the "crack" indicators (breadth, credit turning, jobless claims turning, cross-asset divergence); "fuel" indicators such as euphoria, positioning and valuation are background only. Limits: tops caused by a pure positioning squeeze or an outside shock often show no internal deterioration beforehand, and this model finds them hard to flag early.
Important disclosures This page is generated automatically each week by a deterministic quantitative model; no large language model is used in the scoring. All thresholds and probabilities come from historical back-tests since 2006. Independent market tops are few, and future results may differ. This page is for information only and is not investment advice or an offer to buy or sell. Markets carry risk; invest with care.